Evaluation

I have looked at every aspect involved in this project and evaluated it all, as you can now see below.

Following and Challenging Conventions

A few theories apply to my work. One of these is Todorov;s narrative theory. He proposed a basic structure for all narratives. My film starts with a calm period where the character leads and normal life, which is the equilibrium. It then has disruption through the character potentially losing everything and by his sister being kinapped, which is the disequilibrium and then the chaos comes to an end, which is known as the new equilibrium. This sort of structure is the simplest form of narrative and is sometimes reffered to as ‘classic’ or ‘Hollywood’ narrative as this is what is seen as being the norm for most films. The second type of theory that applies to my work is Propps’s theory surrounding character. He states that there are always 8 types of character which include the hero, the villain, the donor, the dispatcher, the false hero, the helper, the princess and her father. He says that there are only 8 character types and only 31 things that they will ever do, as each character has a sphere of action. This is easily relatable to films and programmes today, and although I do not have all the character types in my plot I have some of the main types such as the victim, the villain and the ‘princess’, meaning that I am following conventions. I think that it is difficult to challenge these types of theories, especially Propp’s as there is only so much that can be done and many film ideas tend to just be old ones reinvented, as it is hard to come up with something entirely new.

!TRAILER TO BE PUT HERE!

All media products use the four aspects that are cinematography, mise en scene, sound and editing, as a way of following and challenging conventions, as they are involved in every visual piece of media. In terms of mise en scene within my trailer, the plot has a planned route, but this is not visible to the audience. The part that they see in the trailer leaves them not knowing what will happen to the characters. The main character, Blake, leads a normal life but one day finds a lottery ticket on the floor. He picks it up and keeps it, later to find that it was a winning ticket in which the prize had not been claimed. His life changes dramatically and some time later we see how his life has changed, with a new house in a sophisticated, expensive area, and a flashy car that shows his new found status. Things go wrong for him when a letter arrives telling him that his sister has been taken hostage and that there is a ransom, which he must face. However, this is to lose everything he owns, and leaves him with nothing. The audience are left not knowing what decision he chooses and the final shot is of the sister lying on the floor tied up not moving, so they are left wondering, is she dead or alive? The kidnapper is in all black to show that he is a negative sinister character that is doing wrong, whereas the other characters are in colour to set them aside from this kind of character. The sound in my trailer is very simple. I decided not to have talking as it gives away too much and through just having music there was a much more dramatic effect given off. I used as heartbeat sound effect and put it in with each cut and also when I wanted the scenes to get dramatic or have tension and suspense. I used a heartbeat instead of just a normal drum sound as it give the feel of it being the main characters heart as he is panicking throughout the trailer, giving a much more personal feel to relate to. As well as this I had a song throughout the trailer being played in the background. It starts off very dragged out and slow, with a piano and violin song, and gets more dramatic and loud towards the end but using the same instruments. I liked the piece of music as it sounded very dramatic and I was able to manipulate it to get the effect I wanted and to make it fit better to the scenes. By having such an elegant and sophisticated piece of music over the top of shocking images creates a juxtaposition that people will be intrigued by and can interpret in their own way, challenging conventions. Finally I used a dialling out tone on a phone at the end of the trailer, which gave the feel of not knowing what was happening but knowing that something would carry on happening, making the viewer want to carry on and know what will happen. Originally I had come up with a script for a voiceover for the majority of the trailer, but once I had filmed this realised that just a few words gave a better effect as it kept more secret and made the parts that where said stand out more and become memorable for the audience. In my trailer piece I tried to use the cinematography in a varied way. I used shots from a variety of angles such as from below, like in the scene where I have the letter coming through the letterbox and when the character steps out of the car, panning shots to reveal him, and also to move up to the hostages face, over the shoulder shots when looking at the lottery ticket and watching television. These are just a few of the angles that I had planned to shoot from a particular angle to make them enticing. Each scene that I filmed I shots a number of times from different angles and then chose the best one, and the one that would continue the variety throughout the trailer. I kept the lighting very neutral to start with to give the every feel so used natural lighting. When things got tenser, for example with the letter I staged some lighting so that it would highlight the important parts such as the name of the person the letter is dressed to. The main part that I played around with the light for was the scene with the kidnap. I wanted the lighting to make the overall mood feel tense due to the dark and sinister colouring, therefore I had the lights dimmed down and had a focus light on the characters and reflecting on the wall. Finally, with the editing in my trailer I kept it fairly basic, with each scene transitioning with mainly dip to black and cross fades. The only part where I tended to use more editing techniques was the end scenes where I flick from the girl being kidnapped to the main character on the phone panicking repeatedly. I used white and black plain screens in short spurts to give a flashing effect, something that I saw in films such as Saw and 28 Days Later and wanted to recreated to feature in my own trailer as it builds suspense. I decided to edit sound into the last bit by stopping the music to give a eerie feel, but having just the dialling out tone. Whilst this was happening I slowly revealed the actors names and the title, with the sound playing over a black screen at the end, giving a mysterious feel.

I created many different ideas for the poster before deciding on a final one as I felt I would get the best out of experimenting with new ideas, and developing on existing ones. For one of the ideas I had I was inspired by the Lily Allen magazine cover, when you are looking from behind her into a mirror. I really liked how this gave a 3D effect which gave the image depth and a lot to look at. I personally felt that it was an interesting way to show an image in a different and unique way. I wanted to recreate this myself and did so, but I felt that due to the feel of my plot, the effect wasn’t as striking, and therefore tried other things. You can see my ideas I came up with in the blog about posters. Eventually I came up with an image where I had changed the colour setting to blue and yellow to add a contrast and to make it bold and stand out, and added the appropriate text in a font that I used throughout all of my work for continuity. With posters there is usually a focal point, which in my poster is the characters face as his emotions are what is supposed to be concentrated on, to have an effect on the audience where they can see his emotions and relate to them.

!POSTER TO BE PUT HERE!

With my magazine cover it tends to follow generic conventions, particularly as I have used an existing magazine to feature my work on instead of creating something original. The effect of this is that it looks professional and polished. I was inspired by Sight and Sound magazine and Electric Sheep magazine as they both use the same house style in each issue, making them instantly recognisable, and making them stand out amongst other similar products, something I want my promotional work to do, stand out. They are also both surrounded by films that are low budget and not produced by big companies just like my film. Both of these magazines use very strong use of bold colours and sharp lines to make them stand out, and use the same fonts and layout with each issue. Therefore, I used their standard layout and applied my work to them. The style is very conventional, and from the audience response I can see that I achieved the same effect as the usual magazines. If I had wanted to challenge conventions I would have either created an entirely new magazine that used the opposite techniques to the ones usually used, or I would have used an existing magazine and changed the generic styling of it, including images that contrast etc to make it new, fresh and stand out.

Effectiveness of Products

Throughout creating the main product, which is my trailer and the ancillary texts, which are the poster and magazine I tried to ensure that they all combine and had the same sort of elements so that the viewers knew they are connected, as other film creators do when advertising and promoting their work. The pieces work together by containing the same elements throughout. I found a really effective font that had a dripping sort of effect coming off of the letters, giving the idea of blood and making the plot seem that bit more dangerous. I ensured that this font was used throughout by having it on the posters and magazine and also by having it in the credits within the trailer. I also tried to stick with the same colour schemes and overall feel through using images that are similar in house style, which is very suave and professional, as the characters are sophisticated and know what they are doing. The genre is a mix between a thriller and a horror. This is because it has a fast pace, and lots going on that effect peoples lives which builds the thriller element, and towards the end of the trailer, in the audience feedback people found the scenes shocking which gave the horror element. I have made the three products tie in together by using the same character as the face of each so that the film is recognisable. It would have done this through the font styling and name but it is easier to remember a face than a name, so I decided to go for the safer option. I felt that the poster is the weaker piece as I should have focused on making it very eye catching and getting a lot of points across. With a magazine cover, there is going to be information inside about the film, and the trailer gives a lot of information, but with the poster, that is all the audience sees, so they judge the film from it, so I felt I should have got more across through it with more special effects and focal points. I might of done this by improving the posing of the model, and also by adding more of the characters into the image. An example of this that I was inspired by is the New Moon promotional posters. Without giving too much away these have a great aura to them and show the genre through the colours and styling. The expressions on the characters faces stay a lot about the mood of the film. Also the font style, is echoed in the previous films, so this is a great example of a house style used in a media product.

Audience Feedback

All media types use audience response within their products, as it is essential to see how the products will do when out on the market, before actually getting them out there fully, as failing products could cost a lot of money. Therefore for example, a new film that has been made will have private screenings before being released, with the audience being from the target market. This gains audience responses and changes can be made before actually being released, something that is very important to ensuring that institutions succeed. According to Stuart Hall’s reception theory, audiences have three reactions to a media text. These include dominant or preferred meaning, opposition reading and negotiated reading. My particular plot and media products have a mainly preferred meaning as I, as the creator, have a meaning that I want to get across, and views that I want to be portrayed. However, I think that there is also an element of negotiated meaning as there are elements that the audience accepts as my views but they also have their own ideas on parts of the story too. The way that the audience interprets and reads my work will depend on geographic and demographics factors that depend on their own personal backgrounds and experiences.
I needed to gain audience response’s so that I could see what worked well with my work and what didn’t so that I can learn and develop upon the criticism, something that is very important to me learning about every aspect of media, as getting to know the audiences and consumers is vital in the industries. Additionally it will also enable me to see where I have done well/badly, as I may have overlooked something that stood out to the viewer. I decided that I would use a combination of methods to collect feedback and responses from the audiences to cover all areas that I needed to learn about. Firstly, I handed out a questionnaire to people, which they where asked to fill out after looking at the posters, magazine cover and trailer. This gives precise answers, giving a quick overview, which is easier to asses and to generate statistics from. Secondly, I decided to use a video documented interview set-up, to show how I can use technology within media, and also an interview is a much more efficient way of getting feedback as the answers given back are much more detailed and opinionated. Also, even though I have a basic set of questions that I will ask, I can spontaneously develop questions based on answers given, giving a more in depth response from the interviewee. I decided that I would gather response from people not only in my target market but outside of it too as this will show whether the aim for my products have worked and if it meets what is conventionally expected, and who it appeals to, as well as the views of those who aren’t part of who it is aimed at. I wanted to keep the topics that I got feedback on similar in both methods I used, but had to adapt the questions slightly as the questionnaire set-up did not cater for questions that required an open ended answer, so I had to ensure that only firm short answers were available, and with the interview I had to ensure that the questions had room for the interviewee to develop upon and discuss.

From the questionnaire I found out about peoples feelings towards the media pieces that I created, and also found out about their cinema habits, which I found to be very rare due to the cost surrounding going to the cinema at the current time. This is something that the industry needs to look into as there has been a serious decline in cinema viewings. However, due to this a raise in internet downloads and DVD sales has been noticed.

I found that by doing method 1, which was a questionnaire, that I got very sturdy closed answers that where great for giving me statistics. I found out that people don’t really tend to go to the cinema very often, something that I decided to ask about in the interview situation later on. As well as asking about their cinema habits I asked about each of my media pieces, to get an overview of opinions. From this I found that people thought that the pieces linked well and liked the plot and how the eventual pieces where put together to build a certain mood and suspense. You can see the full results from the questionnaire in my previous ‘Audience Response’ blog post.

The second method worked really well as I was able to build upon peoples answers depending on what they said and turn it into following questions as the answers where much more open and opinionated personally to the particular people. From doing this I was able to ask why people decided they felt that way about that particular question. You can see the full results on the response video that is within my ‘Audience Response’ blog post.

Overall from my audience feedback I have learnt that what went well in my pieces of work and what needs to be improved, which you can see in detail in my Audience Feedback blog post. I also found that by using different types of audience feedback I can find out what needs to be changed and what works well, in much more detail that if I had used only one method.

!AUDIENCE RESPONSE VIEDO TO BE PUT HERE!

Using Media Technologies

Before embarking on this project I hadn’t has much previous experience using different technologies to create media products, so through doing this coursework it has been a massive learning curve for me. Last year, I used InDesign to create magazine related pieces of work for the AS Coursework, which enabled me to have a basic idea of how some of the programs work in the media. This year however, I have had a much wider variety of technologies, which I have used. These have included things such as digital cameras, camcorders, Adobe Premiere Elements, Photoshop and Indesign.

To begin the project I carried out a lot of Internet and book research as I wanted to have a firm knowledge of the industry, and both how generic conventions are followed, and also challenged, to enable me to come up with ideas and experiment. I looked at the websites, which produce films, magazine websites, and sites such as ‘Empire’, which shows a backlog of film posters. From this I really saw how each media products has a branding to it, in that people stick to different house styles, which enables the consumers to know exactly where to find what they are looking for and what to rely on time and time again. I used the research that I had collected to start making plans for my ideas. I looked at what conventions the successful media products in all three aspects that I had to create media products for.

When I had compiled enough research I created my two ancillary texts. I wanted to create these first as from them I would be able to use the fonts used and echo them into my trailer. I staged a photo shoot and used a digital camera to gather enough images of the characters from different angles, with different settings and lighting positions. I chose the best images and enhanced and manipulated them using Photoshop. When I had done this I used Photoshop and InDesign to add on text. I used fonts from dafont.com as they had a great range of letter styling that would portray moods that I wanted. For the magazine I also added what else was included in the magazine and added on the conventional components of the magazines, such as the titles and backgrounds that are used in each issue.

The bulk of the project was the trailer. This used a number of technologies and methods to complete. Firstly I came up with a shooting schedule and planned out every aspect including, the plot, costumes, settings, props, lighting, angles, and sounds that I needed to collect. I filmed the scenes that I needed multiple times to get the footage that I needed to perfection. I used a digital camcorder to do this and used the aid of a tripod for some scenes. To film the scene when the character is driving along his road I filmed out of a moving car window. I ensured that the conditions where the same each time filming commenced and also that they where controlled and didn’t have unnecessary disturbances such as people walking into the frame when they shouldn’t have. I used Adobe Premiere Elements to cut down the footage, and add in transition effects and sounds. Through the evaluation process I also used a few media methods to get across some points. I created an audience response video interview with peoples opinions on (this can be seen in the audience response blog post). I also used charts and graphs to show statistics from my feedback, so that it can be understood from a quick glance. I had also planned to film my evaluation in the form of a Podcast, something that is used a lot these days especially in Radio to keep people updated, when they want to listen on their own terms. Another idea I also was going to produce was an audio commentary, which would be over the top of the trailer. This would be great to give people an insight into how the ideas behind what happens came about, also showing the hidden meanings and showing my personal interpretation that people may not have recognised immediately. Not many problems arose during the time on this project.

I wanted the audience to respond in a way that is personal to them individually. The sad feelings that are related, that are tied in with the music will affect each person differently. I also wanted people to think about what decisions they would make and also what would be catastrophic to their own lives, something I think that I have achieved as the audience seemed shocked and felt emotional about the trailer. The film will be shown in an art house cinema as it is aimed at a niche audience that are specifically interested in the genre that my film is. Also my film was created on a low budget so wouldn’t make it into a multiplex cinema. I have decided that it is going to be Vertigo Films that are responsible to endorse the production and distribution of my trailer as when I researched into what they do and who they take on the are keen to back commercially driven independent cinema productions that are completed on a low budget. They work closely with Film4 which would be great for the film as it would get it out to the target audience and also would have more advertisement due to this.

Final Film Poster, Magazine Cover and Trailer

I had decided that i wanted to get audience response before deciding on what to use finally, as i had created more than one design on some of the tasks, and felt that the opinion of the audience was most important, as i already liked all of the designs. In the audience feedback post you can see their responses to each and from what was said these are the final products from each task:

Film Poster

Magazine Cover

Trailer

Audience Response

Interview Questions
I have decided that to gain feedback and a firm and clear audience response i am going to interview people from both the target market and outside of the target market, and film them being asked about the film poster, magazine cover, and trailer. I have decided to do this as by filming them and having a physical conversation i feel that i will get more in depth feedback than if i used a questionnaire as people feel more inclined to speak into depth, and expand upon answers. I have thought about what questions i am going to ask so that i get the answers that i need to evaluate my work thoroughly. Below is the set of questions that i have decided to ask and in the order that is best suited.

1. Do you go to the cinema often? What genre of films do you like to watch?

2. By looking at the promotional posters and the magazine cover, what can you tell about the film, and what does it make you expect from it?


3. From watching the trailer how would you describe the concept and how would you summarise it?

4. Who do you think the target audience for the film/trailer is?



5. What are your feelings towards the characters? can you identify or relate to any of them?


6. How did the trailer make you feel?


7. What were your favourite parts of the film trailer?


8. What improvements would you suggest?


9. Is the trailer what you expected from the genre? Do you think it followed generic conventions?


10. Where do you think the trailer would be shown?


11. Do you think that the trailer was effective? What are your general thoughts on the trailer and how i did?


12. Do you think that the trailer, magazine cover and posters link?

13. What rating out of 10 would you give the trailer?

I filmed the responses and this is a video showing them from a selection of people who i interviewed:



From the audience research that i filmed with a selection of people, i learnt a lot, some things that i hadn't actually realised about my work. People said that they thing the cinema is too overpriced which limits them going and they only really go as a social thing when something has been really hyped up and is really good, also that they tend to prefer to watch it online or wait for the DVD to come out. When they do go the most popular genres seemed to be very gender related with the guys liking action and horror, and the females liking comedy and romance. They said that mine appealed to them as it combined thriller elements to appeal to men and aspects that appeal to women such as feeling sorry for characters and people losing things in their lives. The most popular poster that people chose was the blue and yellow coloured one. They liked how different it looked due to the effects used on it and how it really stood out due to the bold colours. The audience pointed out the font and how it was very striking and grabbed their attention as it kind of had the effect of blood dripping off the letters, enticing them in to see what would happen. It had a gangsta feel and made the character look as though something dodgy was happening. I had the posters laid out on the table and that was the one that everybody picked up first. In terms of the magazine, the Electric Sheep magazines grabbed peoples attention most as they had a sophisticated look that was reflected in how the main character was photographed. They said that the title got the message across and showed how the story was going to be styled. The interviewees said that they liked how the story reflected how in real life any person can have their luck change sometimes not out of choice. One person said that they feel the trailer showed that all along even from the beginning it could have been planed, as the ticket looked like it had been there intentionally to entice the character. This was something i hadn't noticed, but can now see, which in a way is good as it means that the trailer can be interpreted in different ways. When asked what target audience the trailer is suitable for the audience response people said between 15 and 25 as it has thriller aspects but isn't too full on or unrealistic. They whee able to empathise and feel sympathy with some of the characters as they felt sorry for the girl and also felt bad that the main character had gone from nothing to having everything to having it stolen away from him, sort of being punished for being lucky. This made them feel grateful for what they have and said it shows that it could happen to anyone in life, working and getting things, but then there being a constant risk of losing everything. The trailer made them feel tense and in suspense, with scenes that hit home and caught their attention. One said that it gave her goosebumps due to the soundtrack which had a powerful juxtaposition between a soft music that was slow, to a fast paced set of imagery with a tense atmosphere. They liked the music in particular and also felt a warmth between the tabloid images as they where a different element to look at, that got across the meaning of the story a bit easier, plus the lottery editing they also liked. The only improvement that they mentioned they had picked up on was the voice over that they felt took away from the trailer as it was too full on and a bit cheesy, when without it the trailer would have stood out against other similar types of film. They expected the sort of ideas that happened but felt that it challenged conventions as it starts lighthearted yet gets very tense and powerful, with a roller coaster ride going from not good to great to very bad, but it didn't get as horrific as they had begun to expect with the introduction of hostage scenes, which made them expect more in the actual film. They felt that the film would be best suited at an arthouse cinema, aimed specifically at a niche audience who are interested particularly in the genre mine fits into. I was very pleased with the ratings that the sample of people gave, with rates of 8, 9 and 10! In my opinion this means that the trailer was a success, and met the needs of the target audience!!
As well as the interview situation i also carried out a paper questionnaire to get firm results that could be quickly referenced to. This also gives closed answers which are great for finding out statistics, whereas an interview situations gives much more open results that have been expanded upon.
This is the final questionnaire:



The results from the questionnaire are as follows:

Question 1:


From the results of this question i can see that the cinema is on average used once a month by people in my target age group. This is as it is something that they like to do socially, and to catch up with the latest films that capture their attention. However, it is very expensive, making it something that is used on a rareish occasion and becomes more of a planned trip. This shows that i need to ensure that my film lives up to expectations to make it worthwhile a visit to the cinema. I could also look into other methods of getting my film out to people. For example i could release the film straight onto DVD, something people find more value for money, or even release it on a site such as iTunes, where people can download it for a lower price, but enabling me to still make money from it.
Question 2:


From this i discovered that theres not a specific kind of genre that people like to watch overall, but its much more varied. People seem to like to watch different films depending on their moods and feelings at the particular time. This is great as it means that at some point a film such as mine could appeal to people. I noticed that something that people really like is lighthearted fun in the form of comedy's and rom-com's, as you don't have to think too much whilst watching them, and generate a great feel of realism.


Question 3:

My target audience for my film is between 17-21 years, which is reflected in the answers given in this questionnaire as the people involved though that the film is aimed at that age range. This is probably due to the content, themes and moods that are given off about the film.


Question 4:



The results of this question have been very pleasing for me as from the answers given i can see that i have succeeded in getting across the meaning of the film and the right moods and emotions can be related to. I wanted to show that people can go from having everything to nothing and vice versa and that no matter how much someone has, they can still have bad things happen and experience bad feelings. I wanted people to therefore be able to relate to that, which i think they can. Also i wanted people to have certain feelings towards certain characters. For example, i wanted them to feel sorry for the kidnapper girl and also Blake the main character as he is has a lot at stake, also there is a slight element of jealousy of what he has despite bad things happening to him. People also felt a great feeling of dislike towards the kidnapper, something i defiantly wanted, as i wanted him to be the villain in the plot.
Question 5:
All the feelings that where relayed in the audience response where ones that i wanted to gain, which is great as it shows that i have correctly put together the film and have used the right kinds of editing to create suspense and used music that will trigger sad emotions.

Question 6:

People found that they weren't able to identify with the situations themselves as it is rare to win the lottery and be involved in other issues raised in the film ideas, however, people found that they were liable to identify with the prospects and emotions of losing someone close and going to any lengths to save them, similar to the ones that the characters in the film where. Also people where able to identify with gaining something and then having it taken away, and the feelings related with that and dealing with getting over it and moving on.

Question 7:


People found that the film followed conventions as it started nice then went bad, it also build suspense in the way other films did with the music and editing, with the cuts and beats. It wasn't however what all of them expected as they didn't expect it to go so drastically wrong for the character and found the scenes of the girl being kidnapped shocking and startling.
Question 8:

From this there is a very definite answer to where the film would be shown, which is in an art house cinema. This was because people felt that it is suited to a particular audience who like specifically that kind of genre, so it would be more suited for them to see it there. Also this is the place it is suited to due to the low budget used to create it.

Question 9:

The marks where all very high on this question which i am pleased with. It shows that the the right images, footage, fonts, colours, wording etc was used. It also shows that it is creating the right effect and mood, that is aesthetically right for the consumer. It shows that it fits with the plot and makes the film identifiable and that it links appropriately.
Question 10:


This was a very important question for me as it is essential that all three link, so that the film has an identity and can be immediately recognised in public places, and on television etc. As you can see from the results here people thought that they did link, mainly through the colour schemes, types of images and the typography designs that where used, that where echoed throughout the three media pieces intentionally.
Question 11:


This was a personal question as i just wanted to see if based on what had been shown would people like to see the film. They all said that they did as the film captured their attention and put them in suspense. By the trailer being left on a cliffhanger they wanted to find out what would happen to the characters and how the problems would be solved as it was left open to many potential options and solutions.

Back to Home Back to Top A2 G324: Kayleigh Dicker. Theme ligneous by pure-essence.net. Bloggerized by Chica Blogger.